Mind/Body Medicine
The new mind/body medicine extends beyond the
parameters of psychoneuroimmunology to include the fields of
psychology and physics in a new "science of consciousness,"
a view which sees energy as the underlying pattern of the universe.
This view sees
human beings as part of an interconnected, universal energy field.
These Eastern traditions (Ayurveda, qigong, yoga) have for
centuries believed that consciousness plays an essential role in
governing physical and psychological health.
Mind/body medicine encompasses the following
basic principles, which are often ignored or unrecognized by
contemporary Western medicine:
Each Person Is Unique
No two people are alike, so even if they have
the same disease, the paths to recovery may be different. The same disease can be the result of different factors with
different people. Although these principles have been long
recognized in Traditional Chinese Medicine and Ayurvedic Medicine,
it is a relatively new concept in Western medicine. One person, for
example, may contract pneumonia as a result of a serious infection
or cold, while someone else may come down with the same disease as a
result of psychological stress. Yet a third person could become
susceptible due to a nutritional or biochemical imbalance. Roger
Williams, Ph.D., a pioneer in biochemistry, called this phenomenon
"biochemical individuality," for he recognized that each
of us is genetically unique, requiring slight variations in nutrient
intake in order to function optimally.
Chronic Stress
A basic premise in mind/body medicine is that chronic
stress and lack of balance contribute to illness. Likewise,
relaxation, positive methods of coping with stress, and restoration
of balance lead to health. More important than the stressors
themselves is the person's ability to cope. When stressors are met
as a challenge and the individual feels competent to cope
effectively, health may be enhanced. On the other hand, stress can
also cause people to turn to desperate measures to try to cope, as
in the case of substance abuse.
Hans Selye, a pioneering stress researcher,
developed the general adaptation syndrome model, in which chronic
activation of the fight or flight response leads to strain on an
organ system over time, and interferes with its ability to adapt.
Ultimately, the system breaks down and illness can set in.
British cardiologist Peter Nixon explains that
increased stress and arousal causes numerous changes in body
functioning that eventually interfere with immune function, protein
synthesis, and cardiac functioning. Repetitive stress also uses up
the body's reserves, leading to increased stress on other
physiological functions. This, in turn, can result in heart disease,
cancer, or depression.
If stress contributes to illness, then stress
reduction should promote curing. This is the basis of numerous
curing modalities such as progressive relaxation, guided imagery,
and biofeedback. Herbert Benson, M.D., of Harvard
University, developed the relaxation
response technique. It is a distillation of basic meditative practice,
which decreases heart rate and blood pressure, enhance health,
and reduce the incidence of illness.
These basic stress reduction practices can be learned and practiced
by anyone.
Mulitiple Personalities
The phenomenon of the multiple personality
patient may offer evidence of how mental states directly affect
physiology. Often a multiple will switch medical conditions when
another personality takes over. By changing personalities, a
multiple can switch physiological states, going from drunk to sober,
sedated to alert, or left to right handed.
John Sward, Ph.D., of the Center for the
Improvement of Human Functioning Inter-national in Wichita, Kansas,
experienced this several years ago when a female patient he was
working with manifested allergies while in a different personality
state. Working along with an allergist who would first test the
woman for a certain allergy, Dr. Sward would then hypnotize her into
a different personality state and the reaction would cease.
Additionally, Dr. Sward found that the allergist could send the
person into a different personality merely by placing different
antigens on her skin.
The ability for a multiple personality
patient to substitute personalities when in pain is an example of
how mind/body medicine can accelerate the curing process.
Taking Self-Responsibility for Healing
Mind/body medicine supports the view that the
patient is an active partner in all stages of treatment, rather than
a passive recipient of medical intervention. Lawrence Le Shan, Ph.D.,
was a pioneer in mind/body medicine for the treatment of cancer. He has
documented that cancer patients who took charge of their life
directions were more likely to recover than those who passively
accepted their diagnosis.
Taking action also decreases the fear and
depression that so often accompanies life-threatening illness. By
becoming actively involved in self-healing, one shifts from the
feelings of helplessness and hopelessness that have been shown to
increase depression and the risk of death to a sense of control.
Immune functions are also affected by the
experiences of helplessness or control. In one study, rats that were
conditioned to experience helplessness were more likely to develop
cancer from injected tumor
cells and die than other rats. Rats that were trained to have a
sense of control were best able to reject the tumor cells.
The Body's Innate Healing Capabilities
The body has a natural, biological tendency to
move toward health and balance, a phenomenon that can be observed in
the simple curing of a cut in which the body automatically closes
the wound and repairs the damage.
The well-known "placebo
effect" (in which a neutral substance is found to effectively
cure an ailment or disease) also demonstrates the body's capacity to
cure itself. Erik Peper, Ph.D., Associate Director of the Institute
for Holistic Healing Studies at San Francisco State University,
suggests that the placebo effect can decrease or remove the
constraints that are interfering with the body's intrinsic drive
toward wholeness. These constraints can include feelings of
helplessness and hopelessness, negative beliefs about the illness,
and negative self-/images.
Jeanne Achterberg, Ph.D., President of the
Association for Transpersonal Psychology, adds that the
effectiveness of the placebo varies depending upon how much
the patient expects to benefit. In other words, those who
think they will get better have a significantly greater recovery
rate than those who think they will not get better, or think they
will get worse.
The Importance of the Client-Provider Relationship
The relationship between the client and the
physician can strongly influence the curing process. For example,
when a physician is perceived as powerful and trustworthy, the
client gets better faster, and one study has even shown that
physician reassurance and support raises the threshold of pain
tolerance in hospital patients.
Mind/body medicine recognizes that the
practitioner is constantly communicating (consciously and
unconsciously) with the client. Just as the placebo
is seen as a way of promoting curing through the patient's belief
system, the positive attitude of the doctor can influence the
outcome of a given treatment, while discouraging statements or
prejudices can evoke what some call a "nocebo" effect by
undermining the patient's confidence and hindering the curing
process.
Unfortunately, this dimension of the
curing
process is rarely noticed or addressed. Thus, a doctor who thinks of
a patient as hopeless will convey this to the patient even if the
thought is unspoken. In the ideal client/provider relationship, the
curing process is viewed as a working partnership in which both
parties respect the knowledge and intuition of the other. In this
respect, the health care provider seeks to convey the potential for
wholeness in each client.
A Systems Approach
Mind/body medicine is based upon a systems
perspective that recognizes that human lives are influenced by many
interrelated factors, including genetics, family and socioeconomic
background, diet, exercise, social support, risk-taking behaviors,
attitudes, and spiritual practices. An illness may be only a
manifestation of imbalance on the physical level, but the imbalance
may also originate in other aspects of the self, such as the mental
or emotional state.
Any movement toward health mobilizes the other
curing potentials of the body. As a person makes a change in one
area, other areas tend to change as well. For example, if a person
begins to exercise, the person may feel more socially confident and
might spontaneously change his eating habits, thus improving
overall physical and emotional health. While any disease may be a
problem in but a small part of the total person, the factors that
influence its manifestation and subsequent healing can be
extraordinarily complex.
The Energy Field Perspective
In human body, there are various fields of energy that can
be measured instrumentally with an EKG (electrocardiograph), an EEG,
(electroencephalograph), or electroacupuncture
biofeedback testing, a method of testing based on
measurement of the electrical properties of acupuncture points.
These energy fields are continuously affected by changes in physical
or psychological health, and can even be influenced by the energy
fields of others.
Robert Becker, M.D., a pioneer in the study of
the effects of electromagnetism on health, found that small electric
currents can stimulate cells to regenerate, fractures to cure faster,
and tissue to repair itself.
Research in neuropsychiatry over the past few decades has also shown
that small electric currents between specific points in the brain
give rise to the same behavioral changes that are observed with the
injection of certain brain-stimulating chemicals.
The energy field perspective can even be applied
to hospital settings. Dolores Krieger, Ph.D., R.N., a former
Professor of Nursing at New York University, has developed a Therapeutic Touch,
a technique which has been proven to be
effective in treating a variety of medical conditions. Therapeutic Touch
is a contemporary
interpretation of several ancient healing practices in which the
practioner consciously directs or sensitively modulates human
energies.
The proper use of Therapeutic Touch can increase
hemoglobin
and decrease anxiety,
reduce pain, accelerate the healing of surgical wounds, and help
correct dysfunctions of the autonomic nervous system.
This technique has been taught to more than 37,000 nurses, doctors,
and health practitioners.
In mind/body medicine, the importance of human touch is greatly
emphasized, especially for children. Dr. Borysenko says, in
a child, absence of touch can cause the pituitary gland not to
secrete enough growth hormone. The
child will dwarf, developing so called ''failure to thrive''
syndrome. The child can't assimilate nutrients and may actually
sicken and die.
Handling and physical affection help to increase the survival rate of infants, improve psychological
skills and functioning, promote physical growth and immune function,
and, most importantly, enable a person to respond effectively to
stress. Also, autopsies on rats that were given extra handling and care
showed much less damage to their cardiovascular
and intestinal systems than those who were not handled.
Illness as Message, Not Enemy
In many ways, contemporary medicine
carries the
notion of all-out war against disease, in which illness is seen as
an enemy and death as a failure. Mind/body medicine sees an illness as a communication from the body, a warning signal
that something needs attention. People can use this "message"
to review the entire mind/body system and see how it is functioning
as a whole. If a person experiences back pain, he might ask,
"Am I carrying too much emotional weight? Am I under too much
stress? Am I using my body properly or exercising it well?"
In mind/body medicine, one looks beyond the
immediate problem to include a larger dimension of one's life. For
example, a heart attack may be a signal for a person to become less
defensive and hostile, to become less competitive at work, and to
give more attention to relaxation, hobbies, family, and the
enjoyment of life. In this process a person's heart will cure both
literally and symbolically.