Benefits of Biofeedback Training
Biofeedback training is very useful for health and prevention, particularly in cases where
psychological factors play a role. Sleep disorders, hyperactivity in
children, and other behavioral disorders respond well to biofeedback
training, as do dysfunctions stemming from inadequate control over
muscles or muscle groups. Incontinence, postural problems, back pain,
temporomandibular joint syndrome (TMJ), and even loss of control due
to brain or nerve damage have all shown improvement when patients
undergo biofeedback training.
Biofeedback can also help people with
such problems as heart dysfunctions, gastrointestinal disorders (acidity,
ulcers, irritable bowel syndrome), difficulty swallowing, esophageal
dysfunction, ringing in the ears, twitching of the eyelids, fatigue,
and cerebral palsy. Severe structural problems like broken bones and
slipped discs are among the only conditions that don't respond to
biofeedback.
Stress-Related Disorders
Biofeedback
training is commonly used for the treatment of stress and stress-related disorders,
including insomnia, TMJ, migraines, asthma, hypertension,
gastrointestinal disorders, and muscular dysfunction.
Insomnia: Biofeedback can often
successfully treat insomnia as long as the appropriate form of
biofeedback is used with the specific, corresponding type of
insomnia. Melvyn
Werbach, M.D., Assistant Clinical Professor at the UCLA School of
Medicine and Director of the Biofeedback Medical Clinic in Tarzana,
California says, that biofeedback is appropriate when insomnia is due to
overactivation of the autonomic nervous system. In this case biofeedback of muscle tension
and skin dampness is used in conjunction with general relaxation techniques.
EEG biofeedback, however, seems useful
when insomnia is due to a mental/emotional problem, not a physical
problem. That's why Dr.Werbach uses it particularly with people who have a problem with
obsessive thinking when they try to go to sleep. Their bodies relax
very nicely, but they just can't get their minds off of whatever it
is that their minds go to. This is when EEG biofeedback is most
effective.
Temporomandibular Joint Syndrome: Dr.
Werbach also reports using biofeedback to successfully treat TMJ. He
recalls the most dramatic case in his practice: a patient who came to the UCLA Pain Control Unit after using bite
plates in his mouth to stop the teeth from grinding together. His
last bite plate had been a metal one, prescribed by a dentist who
thought it would finally solve the problem. Instead, he bit through
the metal. He had severe pain in all the typical areas associated
with TMJ, and was quite depressed about the whole thing. He had
tried everything. Working with him, they took biofeedback readings
from the masseter muscle (the muscle involved in closing the jaw)
and using them, trained him to relax his jaw. Since he was so
preoccupied with his mouth, we also worked on reducing general
muscle tension in the rest of his body by teaching him relaxation
techniques through control of his breathing and surface finger
temperature. It was strikingly effective.
Migraines: The use of biofeedback to
treat migraines began as a chance discovery at the Menninger Clinic
(previously Menninger Foundation) in the early l960s. Elmer Green,
Ph.D., and Alyce Green were measuring a woman's skin temperature to
track her physiological changes while undergoing a series of
relaxation exercises. They noticed a sudden ten-degree increase in
the woman's hand temperature. When asked, she reported that she had been experiencing
a
headache, and it had disappeared at that very
moment.
The Greens tought patients how to lessen migraines
simply by using relaxation techniques to raise the temperature of
their hands.According to a report by Steven L. Fahrion, Ph.D., Director of the
Center for Applied Psychophysiology at the Menninger Clinic,
biofeedback can also reduce the dosages of drugs needed
to combat migraines, and sometimes remove them altogether,
Asthma: Especially well
to biofeedback training responds asthma. A recent fifteen-month follow-up study of
seventeen asthmatics, trained with biofeedback to increase their
inhalation volume, found that all of the participants reported fewer
emergency room visits, a lowered need for medication, and decreased
instance and severity of wheezing attacks. The authors of the study,
Erik Peper, Ph.D., and Vicci Tibbets of San Francisco State
University, concluded, that the subjects knew they had control over their
breathing by learning to increase their
inhalation volume. This experience reduced their fear so that they could
continue to exhale and inhale air during the onset of wheezing.
Hypertension: Biofeedback training is an
effective tool for teaching people self-regulation and relaxation to
help lower blood pressure.
The greatest successes in controlling hypertension are with patients
who combine biofeedback training with other forms of relaxation,
visualization, exercise, and a low-salt diet.
Gastrointestinal Disorders: A specialist in the
application of biofeedback to gastrointestinal disorders of Culver City, California,
Robert Grove reports
great success in treating irritable bowel syndrome, colitis, a wide
variety of eating disorders (including bulimia
and anorexia), heartburn, and functional dyspepsia
(a digestive disorder marked by stomachache, heartburn, or nausea).
Dr. Grove uses motility (movement) retraining, wherein special
sensors are able to pick up movement in the digestive tract and
train it. He explains, that gastrointestinal disorder is a specialty area
and other forms of biofeedback will fail
under these conditions. For one thing, gastrointestinal disorder
patients seem to be hyper-reactive to all types of stimuli such as a
light being turned on or a telephone ringing-things that normally
don't bother other patients. The gastrointestinal tract responds to
these stimuli by shutting down, and biofeedback helps focus in on
protecting or creating a protection from the arousal. The
Menninger Clinic also successfully treats many people for
gastrointestinal disorders, including Crohn's disease (a chronic
inflammatory condition affecting the colon and/or terminal part of
the small intestine) and ulcerative colitis.
Muscular Dysfunctions: Marjorie K. Toomim,
Ph.D., Director of the Biofeedback Institute of Los Angeles, uses
EMG biofeedback to detect muscle imbalances in order to prevent and
correct injuries. For example, a runner with problem knee muscles
was hooked to the EMG, and Dr. Toomim was immediately able to see
that the runner was placing a disproportionate amount of her weight
to one side. The muscles on the inside of the leg were diagnosed as
stronger than those on the outside. To correct the imbalance the
patient needed to exercise only the outer thigh muscles. While
hooked up to the EMG feedback device, the patient could see exactly
when the weaker outside muscles were exercising and when the
stronger inner muscles were at rest. Dr. Toomim says, that in this
case, the EMG gave them information they couldn't have gotten in any
other way, and it enabled the patient to take control of her own
muscular re-education.
Dr. Werbach believes biofeedback training is
sometimes more effective than surgery for patients with back
problems. By teaching patients both relaxation techniques and
control over their muscle spasms, biofeedback helps them reduce or
expel back pain.
Psychologist Bernard Brucker of the University
of Miami Medical School uses EMG biofeedback to teach patients with
serious spinal injuries to walk again. Sophisticated EMG feedback
replaces the sensation of motion lost by spinal cord injury, reduces
muscle spasm, detects activity in muscles mistakenly believed to
lack energy, and strengthens muscles so they function once again.
Yale University research affiliate and Professor
Emeritus at Rockefeller University, Neal E. Miller, along with Barry
Dworkin, Ph.D., of Penn State University, developed a small
biofeedback device worn on the body to treat curvature of the spine.
When the wearer slouches forward, a soft beep is emitted; if he does not straighten up, a piercing alarm goes off. Several
studies have shown it to be especially effective in treating
kyphosis, a front-to-back curvature.
Biofeedback can also successfully treat incontinence. A $13 billion a year problem among institutionalized
elderly, it results when people lose the ability to control the
muscles used for urination or defecation.
A recent report from the Department of Health and Human Services
analyzed twenty-two different studies and concluded that muscular
reeducation through biofeedback training had a success rate ranging
from 54 to 95 percent, depending on the patient group.
History of Biofeedback
O.
Hobart Mowrer was the first who nstrumented biofeedback (in 1938), when he used an alarm system triggered by
urine to stop bed-wetting in children. But it was not until the late
1960s, when Barbara Brown, Ph.D., at the Veterans Administration
Hospital in Sepulveda, California, and Elmer Green, Ph.D., and Alyce
Green of the Menninger Foundation in Topeka, Kansas, used EEG
biofeedback to observe and record the changed states/self-regulation
of yogis, that biofeedback began to attract widespread attention.
The Greens' work with yogis, and the
work of Joe Kamiya to teach subjects to experience a 'drugless high' brought biofeedback to public notice.
Articles on
biofeedback appeared in national newspapers and magazines, and there started to be
the great interest to the idea of
higher states of consciousness.
An Unusual Success Story
Melvyn Werbach, M.D., former Assistant
Clinical Professor at UCLA Medical School and director of the
Biofeedback Medical Clinic in Tarzana, California, was once
approached by a woman whose husband had been in a coma for several
months. Dr. Werbach and his colleague arranged to hook the man up to
various biofeedback devices in an attempt to communicate with him.
While Dr. Werbach monitored the biofeedback equipment, his colleague
asked the comatose patient to concentrate on specific areas of his
body. To everyone's surprise, the galvanic skin response monitor
began to move with the request. Although he was in a coma, the
patient was able to hear. At the end of the session, the family and
staff were shocked to hear him moan loudly.
Perhaps catalyzed by the biofeedback
communication, the patient came out of his coma within a month of
this initial session. Almost two years later, Dr. Werbach got a call
from the patient. He says that hearing patient's voice was one
of the greatest reward in the practice of medicine.
Biofeedback Training as a Visualization Tool
Because biofeedback training enables patients
by teaching them to control one or more of their body processes, it
is proving a useful addition to conventional therapies for cancer and
other chronic
diseases. Dr. Norris uses biofeedback training to teach cancer
patients and patients with AIDS and other immune system disorders to
reduce stress. Using imagery and visualization, she helps patients
to become confident in the ability for self-regulation of their
bodies. Her first cancer patient, nine-year-old Garrett Porter,
overcame an inoperable brain tumor
with the help of biofeedback-assisted visualization.
Now more than a decade later, upwards of three
hundred cancer patients have been studied at the Menninger Clinic
with results ranging from increased comfort and reduced stress to a
complete recovery from cancer.